A Comparative Analysis of the NIFTY ESG and NIFTY100 Traditional Indices: Financial Performance and Crisis Resilience in the Indian Market
AUTHORS: Aditi Natasha Bhuinyan and Ayush Paul ABSTRACT This study evaluates the financial performance and crisis resilience of ESG-focused versus traditional equityindices in India. Using daily data from April 2011 to December 2024, it compares the NIFTY ESG Index with theNIFTY100 Traditional Index across cumulative returns, volatility, Sharpe ratios, and maximum drawdowns. Theanalysis reveals that the ESG index consistently outperforms the traditional benchmark, delivering highercumulative and risk-adjusted returns while maintaining comparable or lower downside risk. During periods ofmarket stress, notably the COVID-19 pandemic, ESG investments demonstrated superior resilience, with lowervolatility, faster recovery, and stronger Sharpe ratios. These findings suggest that ESG integration enhances bothlong-term financial performance and portfolio stability, challenging the notion that sustainable investing requiressacrificing returns. The study provides robust empirical evidence that ESG considerations in India cansimultaneously support profitability, risk management, and sustainable growth, highlighting their strategic valuefor investors, corporations, and policymakers seeking to align financial objectives with long-term sustainabilitygoals.
