IISPPR

Category: Public Policies

Public Policies
Nandini Singh

Intersectionality in Indian Politics: Beyond Age and Gender

Intersectionality in Indian Politics: Beyond Age and Gender Anmol Yadav, Nandini Singh & Divyasri S N   1.Introduction By Anmol Yadav     A crucial perspective for comprehending how caste, class, age, gender, and other characteristics interacting to influence political inclusion in India is intersectionality. This chapter compares the advantages enjoyed by others with the exacerbated obstacles encountered by marginalized groups, such as young women from underprivileged castes or rural areas. It draws attention to the systemic difficulties and achievements of people negotiating these intersections through case studies and historical research. The chapter examines present policies, highlighting their inadequacies in dealing with the complexities of crossing identities, and advocates for a more integrated approach to policy making. Intersectionality-based quotas, capacity-building efforts, and increased data collecting are among the recommendations for promoting inclusive government. Moving beyond isolated issues of youth and gender, this chapter advocates for a comprehensive framework that promotes equal representation and guarantees that India’s political system reflects its population’s variety.   2.Defining Intersectionality By Anmol Yadav   The term “intersectionality” coined by Kimberlé Crenshaw describes how overlapping social identities result in distinct experiences of privilege or disadvantage. Intersectionality is very important in India, as caste, religion, gender, class, and geography all influence society. Just as young tribal men face different hurdles than urban youth, Dalit women face different political obstacles than upper-caste women. By providing insights into systemic disparities, intersectionality aids in the dissection of these overlapping inequalities. It finds chances for alliances and group efforts in addition to examining marginalization. By incorporating intersectionality into Indian politics, officials may promote inclusive representation and address the underlying causes of inequality.   3.Understanding Intersectionality in Indian Politics By Anmol Yadav   3.1 Historical Perspective   Since the independence movement brought disparate groups together, intersectional identities have developed in Indian politics. While individuals like Jawaharlal Nehru and Mahatma Gandhi promoted an inclusive worldview, leaders like B.R. Ambedkar tackled caste-based inequality in addition to colonial tyranny. Women, Dalits, Muslims, and tribal people made substantial contributions while being marginalized in popular narratives; figures such as Sarojini Naidu, Begum Rokeya, and Ambedkar brought attention to the interaction of caste, class, gender, and religion. Demands for linguistic and cultural recognition led to the linguistic restructuring of states in 1956, which was a turning point in identity politics. Caste and class dynamics interacted with regionalism, as seen by statehood movements in Gujarat, Maharashtra, and Andhra Pradesh. Crucial events highlighted the links between caste and class, such as the Mandal Commission’s recommendations for OBC reservations in the 1980s. Similarly, the 1985 Shah Bano case brought attention to the linkages of religion and gender in political discourse. These instances show how caste, gender, and religion have a significant impact on Indian politics.   3.2 Theoretical Framework   Kimberlé Crenshaw’s introduction of the idea of intersectionality offers a useful prism through which to examine the overlapping and interconnected systems of privilege and discrimination. Ambedkar’s views on gender and caste in India are highly relevant to intersectional research. Caste, according to Ambedkar, was a system of gradated inequality that afflicted women and Dalits in diverse ways. Additionally, intersectionality is consistent with feminist ideas that challenge gender-based inequalities and Marxist theories that tackle class injustice. Scholars such as Gopal Guru, Kancha Ilaiah, and Uma Chakravarti have developed similar frameworks in India, looking at the ways that gender, caste, and class interact to influence the lived experiences of marginalized groups. Guru’s idea of “Dalit women’s standpoint” draws attention to the unique difficulties that Dalit women  encounter as a result of being marginalized in both patriarchal and caste systems. The ability of intersectionality to examine the interactions between many identities within the socio-political environment makes it applicable to comprehending Indian political systems.   REFERENCES Intersectionality and Political Mobilization: Exploring How Gender Intersects with Other Identities, such as Ethnicity, Religion, and Economics Psychology of Intersectionality of Gender as Well as Other Forms of Identity: Obstacles and Dilemmas Confronting Women’s Participation in Policy Making-Vandana Singh Electing Women in Ethnically Divided Societies: Candidates, Campaigns, and Intersectionality in Bihar, India Mapping the Margins: Intersectionality, Identity Politics, and Violence Against Women of Color- Kimberle Crenshaw “Intersectionality in Practice: Reflecting on India’s Affirmative Action Policies” by Surinder Jodhka in Economic and Political Weekly (EPW).   4. Contemporary Relevance of Intersectionality in Politics  By Nandini Singh 4.1. Case Studies of Political Leaders Several political leaders in India embody the principles of intersectionality, challenging multiple axes of marginalization. Mayawati, a Dalit woman leader, redefined political power structures as the four-time Chief Minister of Uttar Pradesh. Chandrashekhar Azad, the leader of the Bhim Army, has emerged as a voice for Dalit rights while aligning with broader issues of constitutional democracy and social justice.  Grace Banu, a Dalit transgender activist, challenges systemic exclusion through advocacy for transgender rights. Her political engagement highlights how caste and gender identity compound discrimination, reinforcing the need for inclusive policy making. 4.2. Discussion (Palanithurai, 2005) Studies have shown that female political representatives are more concerned with social issues such as health, poverty alleviation, community development, and family welfare. Gender equality is an essential element for the sustainable progress of any nation. The goal of all- round development of the nation can be achieved only by ensuring the equal participation of both genders in various fields. In India, women are worshiped as goddesses and on the other hand, they are discriminated against. If seen, the root cause of gender inequality in Indian society lies in the patriarchal system. Eminent sociologist Sylvia Walby studied the patriarchal system prevalent in Indian society, stating that “Patriarchalism in the process and system of social structure in which man dominates, oppresses and exploits women”. The exploitation of women due to gender differences is an age-old cultural phenomenon of Indian society. The patriarchal system in the society has gained its legitimacy and acceptance from our religious beliefs, be it Hindu, Muslim or any other religion. Gender-based discrimination is widespread in India. Here, from birth to death, from education to employment, from family to political level,

Read More »
Public Policies
Piyush Chaudhary

Redefining Algorithmic governance: AI for People, Policy and Progress

The article, “Redefining Algorithmic Governance: AI for People, Policy, and Progress,” explores the evolving role of artificial intelligence in shaping public policy in India. It examines how AI is being integrated into governance, from predicting drought patterns to streamlining welfare distribution; while highlighting the challenges of algorithmic opacity, data privacy, and systemic bias. The piece raises critical questions about power dynamics in AI-driven decision-making, questioning whether true authority lies with the coder designing the algorithm, the policymaker implementing it, or the AI system itself. It draws comparisons with global AI governance models, such as the EU’s risk-based regulations, China’s state-driven approach, and the US’s corporate-influenced strategies to position India’s path forward.

Going beyond mere critique, the article presents concrete policy recommendations. It calls for the creation of an Independent AI Ethics Authority (AIEA) to oversee AI deployment, the adoption of Algorithmic Impact Assessments (AIA) to evaluate AI’s social and economic consequences, and the promotion of inclusive AI design to safeguard marginalized communities. Ultimately, the article argues that AI is not just a technological tool but a political force, capable of either reinforcing inequalities or driving inclusive progress. It emphasizes the need for transparent, accountable, and people-centric AI governance to ensure that technological advancements serve democratic values and the public good.

Read More »
Public Policies
Chhavi Thakur

Ethical AI Frameworks for Financial Inclusion in Developing Economies: A Case Study of India

Incorporating Artificial Intelligence (AI) in financial services can significantly improve financial inclusion in developing countries, especially in India, where a large segment of the population is either unbanked or inadequately served. Nonetheless, the application of AI in this area presents ethical dilemmas, such as bias, insufficient transparency, concerns regarding data privacy, and the possibility of marginalizing disadvantaged groups. This research paper aims to tackle these issues by creating a context-specific ethical AI framework designed for the Indian financial sector, focusing on principles of fairness, inclusivity, and accountability.

Read More »
Public Policies
Sakshi Sharma

BREAKING BARRIERS: WOMEN IN BUSINESS

Women’s entrepreneurship drives economic growth and promotes gender equality in India. Despite this, many women face financial and digital hurdles that hinder their involvement. Initiatives from the government, such as Stand-Up India and Mahila e-Haat, aim to provide financial support and access to digital marketplaces, helping women entrepreneurs thrive. This study uses various cases to illustrate these programs’ positive effects while addressing ongoing challenges like financial illiteracy and bureaucratic barriers. To overcome these challenges steps like financial inclusion, digital literacy, and mentorship opportunities, can be taken to empower women-led businesses and create a more inclusive economy.

Read More »
Public Policies
Shristi Meel

INTERSECTION OF FARM LAWS AND FARMERS: BALANCING REFORMS, RESISTANCE AND SUSTAINABILITY

This study explores the impact of India’s 2020 farm laws on farmers, examining the reforms, resistance sparked, and their broader implications for agricultural sustainability. These laws aim to modernize the sector by increasing market freedom and reducing government control. Supporters believed it would empower farmers by providing more selling options, while critics feared it would favor big corporations and undermine Minimum Support Price (MSP) protection. Massive protests led to the laws being repealed in 2021, highlighting farmer concerns.

Read More »
Public Policies
MUSKAN JAISWAL

NITI AAYOG’S SDG INDIA INDEX REPORTS: AN ASSESSMENT OF SELECTED CASE STUDIES

The MoSPI’s 2022 publication “Guidance on Monitoring Framework on SDGs at the sub-national Level” inter alia includes the guidelines for the development of SDG-based National Indicator Framework (NIF) and State Indicator Framework (SIF), which facilitates localization and assists State Governments in the development and refinement of the sub-national level monitoring framework by providing comprehensive guidance. In consonance with the MOSPI’s NIF and SIF, NITI Aayog has released four reports titled ‘SDG India Index,’ covering indices for 2018-19, 2019-20, 2020-21, and 2023-24 based on the globally accepted Sustainable Development Solution Network (SSDN) methodology. These reports illustrate the challenges respective States/UTs face in monitoring SDGs at the sub-national level, along with the best practices being followed in the States/UTs for SDG monitoring. This mechanism of monitoring through indigenized dashboards has facilitated Evidence-Based Policy Making (EBPM) in Indian policy circles. These tools evaluate the performance of the states and union territories aligned with the NIF, providing both goal-wise scores, ranking, and a composite score (0-100) that reflects overall progress collated from the raw data. (PIB, 2024). Thus, the following article undertakes four case studies (i.e., Delhi, Telangana, Uttar Pradesh, and West Bengal) to assess and delineate the attempts of SDG localization on the ground.

Read More »
Public Policies
MUSKAN JAISWAL

TRACKING IMPLEMENTATION OF THE SDGs LOCALIZATION: SELECTED COMPARATIVE CASE STUDIES OF INDIAN DISTRICTS

When the world is counting down the time to fulfill the 17 SDGs and associated 169 targets set for the Agenda @2030, countries adopt the tailored solution of SDGs localization for the faster addressal of the global risks, especially, with popular and enigmatic narratives like ‘Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikaas, Sabka Vishwaas and Sabka Prayaas’ in India. Thus, this paper undertakes the four selected comparative case studies of Indian districts to examine the country’s progress and loopholes in implementing SDG localization, namely, I.) North West (Delhi), ii.) Hyderabad (Telangana), iii.)Noida (Uttar Pradesh), and iv.)Kolkata (West Bengal). The paper employs a mixed methodology of qualitative and quantitative analysis of the synchronized data, i.e. National Indicator Framework (NIF) and District Indicator Framework (DIF) released by the nodal agencies responsible for the SDGs tracking in the respective locale in alignment with the Global Indicator Framework (GIF).

Read More »
Public Policies
Piyush Chaudhary

Mental Health Crisis in Rural India : Challenges and Solutions

Mental health in rural India is a silent crisis—deeply rooted in stigma, lack of awareness, and poor access to care. While urban centers have made progress, millions in villages still struggle without proper diagnosis or treatment. This article dives into the harsh realities of mental health in rural India, the policies in place, and what needs to change.

From the myths surrounding mental illness to the severe shortage of trained professionals, the challenges are overwhelming. But there is hope. Successful interventions, like community health programs and telepsychiatry, are proving that change is possible. With the right policies and awareness, we can bridge the gap and make mental healthcare accessible to all.

Want to be part of the solution? Explore key policy recommendations and real-world case studies that can help transform mental health support in rural India.

Read More »